Victim Mentality in Chronic Illness and Why It’s Problematic

This article explores the concept of victim mentality in the context of chronic illness. It addresses coping patterns, helplessness, blame, and emotional distress. Readers who are currently struggling, or who have experienced medical gaslighting and trauma, may find parts of this discussion triggering. Please take care while reading. Importantly, this article distinguishes between genuine victimhood and a victim mentality as a mindset - the former acknowledges the reality of suffering and injustice; the latter cements it as the sole lens through which life is interpreted. If you are navigating genuine victimhood but do not generally have a victim mindset, this piece is not intended for you.

Chronic illness can bring immense physical, emotional, and social challenges. Symptoms may be relentless, treatments may fail, and healthcare systems may disappoint. These realities can leave anyone feeling powerless. However, for some, this sense of powerlessness evolves into a victim mentality - a habitual way of interpreting life through the lens of helplessness, blame, and defeat. While being a victim of illness is a reality no one chooses, adopting a victim mindset as an ongoing identity can create barriers to coping, adaptation, and, in some cases, recovery.

Victim mentality in general is a persistent way of thinking and feeling in which a person habitually sees themselves as the victim of circumstances, other people, or life itself, regardless of objective reality. It involves externalizing blame, avoiding personal responsibility, resisting feedback, and often relying on sympathy or attention as a primary coping strategy. This mindset fosters negative self-talk, pessimism, and an external locus of control, which undermine agency, limit personal growth, and can create unhealthy relationship dynamics. While it may stem from genuine past experiences of powerlessness, when it becomes ingrained it can be self-defeating and, in some cases, is linked to personality disorders where it functions as a defense mechanism against deeper feelings of shame, inadequacy, or abandonment.

While victim mentality can develop as a way of coping with relentless symptoms, failed treatments, or invalidation from the medical system, it's ultimately disempowering. It fosters cycles of helplessness, resentment, and passivity that make adapting to chronic illness more difficult. Some of the underlying causes of a victim mentality may include prolonged medical trauma, repeated invalidation, and complex post-traumatic stress disorder (CPTSD). These experiences can erode trust, reinforce fear, and make it harder for individuals to recognize their own agency in managing illness. Understanding these roots helps us approach the topic with compassion while still recognizing the harm of remaining stuck in this mindset.

As mentioned above, a core feature of victim mentality is externalizing blame. In chronic illness, this may mean holding the healthcare system, unsupportive family members, or sheer bad luck solely responsible for one’s suffering. While these factors can be real and valid, focusing exclusively on them can strip away a sense of agency. If the source of all problems is seen as external and unchangeable, then even small, manageable steps toward improvement may be dismissed as futile.

This often pairs with avoiding personal responsibility; not in denying the illness itself, but in resisting any exploration of how lifestyle choices, coping patterns, or mindset might be influencing symptoms or quality of life. In conditions where stress, emotional trauma, or mind-body mechanisms play a role, this avoidance can block engagement with potentially helpful therapies. When every suggestion for change is perceived as blame or invalidation, it becomes difficult to try new approaches that might make a difference.

Another common pattern is difficulty accepting feedback, which can significantly hinder both personal growth and the management of chronic illness. Input from doctors, psychologists, therapists, or loved ones - whether it concerns treatment options, coping strategies, or lifestyle adjustments - may be met with defensiveness if it challenges the established narrative of helplessness or invalidates the person’s current way of coping. Feedback, even when offered with compassion and practical intent, can be perceived as criticism, judgment, or a denial of the person’s lived experience. This defensiveness not only blocks potentially helpful information but can also strain relationships, as others may feel dismissed, unappreciated, or unable to offer support without triggering conflict. Over time, this dynamic reinforces the belief that “no one understands” or that others are against them, which deepens mistrust, fuels emotional withdrawal, and increases isolation - ultimately cutting the person off from resources and relationships that could aid in their well-being and resilience.

Victim mentality can also involve seeking sympathy or attention as a primary source of emotional support. Compassion is crucial for those living with chronic illness, but when relationships revolve exclusively around caretaking, both the person with the illness and their support network can become stuck; one reliant on constant validation, the other emotionally drained. Over time, this dynamic can shrink social support rather than strengthen it.

A sustained victim mindset often fosters negative self-talk and pessimism, fueling statements like “I’ll never get better” or “Nothing will work.” These beliefs can erode motivation to experiment with symptom management strategies and can even worsen health outcomes by keeping the nervous system in a prolonged state of stress. The underlying belief system is typically tied to an external locus of control, the conviction that life is shaped entirely by forces outside one’s influence. While this belief may have roots in real past experiences of medical neglect or dismissal, holding onto it long-term can undermine any opportunity for self-directed progress.

In some cases, a chronic victim mentality may overlap with traits from certain personality disorders, such as borderline, histrionic, or narcissistic patterns. These can amplify emotional reactivity, sensitivity to perceived slights, and the tendency to externalize blame. Here, the victim stance may function as a defense mechanism, protecting against deeper feelings of shame, inadequacy, or fear of abandonment. While not all individuals with chronic illness and a victim mentality have a personality disorder, this overlap can make therapeutic intervention more complex, and more necessary.

Therapies such as Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT), Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT), and Compassion-Focused Therapy (CFT) can be particularly helpful in addressing victim mentality. CBT works to identify and challenge unhelpful thought patterns such as externalizing blame or expecting the worst, and replace them with more balanced perspectives that foster a sense of agency. ACT complements this by teaching individuals to accept difficult emotions and circumstances without becoming stuck in them, while encouraging actions guided by personal values rather than avoidance or helplessness. You can read more about acceptance in chronic illness here as this is a much misunderstood concept.

DBT is particularly helpful when a victim mindset is linked to emotional dysregulation or traits associated with borderline personality disorder, as it focuses on building essential skills in distress tolerance, emotional regulation, mindfulness, and interpersonal effectiveness, which together reduce defensiveness and improve relationships. CFT helps to counteract the shame, self-criticism, and dependency on external validation often present in victim mentality by cultivating a kinder, more supportive inner voice. Together, these approaches can validate the reality of a person’s struggles while empowering them to take active, constructive steps toward change.

Recognizing the difference between genuine victimhood and a victim mentality is crucial. The former acknowledges the reality of suffering and injustice; the latter cements it as the sole lens through which life is interpreted. For those living with chronic illness, letting go of a victim mindset does not mean denying pain or invalidating struggle, it means reclaiming even the smallest degree of agency. Shifting from “there’s nothing I can do” to “there are steps I can take” can be the beginning of a more empowered, resilient approach, one that honors both the limitations of illness and the possibilities that still remain.

Ultimately, acknowledging the real suffering caused by chronic illness does not mean reinforcing a mindset of helplessness. A shift from “nothing can be done” toward “I can take steps, however small, toward improving my situation” can mark the beginning of a more empowered, resilient approach; one that honours both the reality of the illness and the capacity for growth despite it.

If this is something you’ve been affected by, please leave a comment below. If there’s something important you’d like to add, please do so. I'd love to hear from you.

If you liked this post or know someone who might find it useful, please share. You can also join my mailing list at www.ingelathuneboyle.com for regular blog notifications straight to your inbox! Please check out my other blog posts here.

------------------------------------------------

Dr. Ingela Thuné-Boyle is a licensed Practitioner Health Psychologist and a Doctor in Behavioural Medicine who specializes in stress and loss, especially in improving the quality of life of people struggling with long-term health problems, chronic pain and trauma. She runs a private online (telehealth) practice at www.ingelathuneboyle.com.

Please note: Advice given in this blog is not meant to take the place of therapy or any other professional advice. The opinions and views offered by the author is not intended to treat or diagnose, nor is it intended to replace the treatment and care that you may be receiving from a licensed physician or mental health provider. The author is not responsible for the outcome or results following their information and advice on this blog.